A year after Julie James (Jennifer Love Hewitt) dealt with the brutal murders of her high school friends, she has fled her hometown to attend college in Boston and leave the painful memories of the past behind her.

Despite her best efforts to lead a normal life, the past has caught up to her. On the one-year anniversary of last summer’s tragic deaths, her grades and romance are slipping and she needs a break. Her best friend Karla (Brandy) sweeps them (along with their boyfriends) off for a Bahamas vacation. When they arrive, however, the island getaway turns into a vacation of murder and mayhem that leaves Julie James, once again, running for her life…